Nov 282010
 

Diplomatic catastrophe’


Major media organizations, including The Guardian and The New York Times, have published detailed reports on a massive trove of leaked US diplomatic cables.

The files address negative perceptions of various world leaders, repeated calls for US attack on Iran, and requests for US diplomats to spy on other countries’ officials.

The White House has described the leaks as “reckless and dangerous”.

There are several explosive revelations contained within the documents including diplomatic notes detailing how Arab leaders in the Gulf have been urging an attack on “evil” Iran.

The documents reveal serious fears in Washington over the security of Pakistan’s nuclear weapons program.

They also detail advice given to US diplomats on how to gather intelligence and pass information of interest over to the country’s spy agencies. According to media reports, senior UN figures were the target of intelligence gathering by US diplomats.

The cache of documents contain allegations of corruption against foreign leaders, who are subjected to stinging criticism in the cables, with Vladimir Putin referred to as an “alpha-dog.”

Angela Merkel “avoids risk and is rarely creative”, and Hamid Karzai is described as being “driven by paranoia.”

World leaders have scrambled to contain the diplomatic fallout in advance of the expected full release by Wikileaks of the full set of cables later on Sunday.

The limited release comes one day after the US state department’s lawyer threatened legal action over publication of the confidential material, obtained by an unknown source.

Meanwhile, Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, has said the release of the classified  documents by the whistle-blower website will amount to a “diplomatic history” of global affairs.

“The material that we are about to release covers essentially every major issue in every country,” Assange told reporters in Jordan by video link from an undisclosed location on Sunday.

US officials took the unusual step on Saturday of sending a letter to WikiLeaks to warn against the release of the secret government documents, which it says will put “countless” lives at risk.

The letter, from Harold Hongju Koh, the US state department’s top lawyer, argued that publishing the classified files would threaten counterterrorism operations and jeopardize US relations with its allies.

“No single individual has even come to harm as a result of anything that we have ever published,” Assange said on Sunday.

The classified documents reportedly cover correspondence between US diplomatic missions abroad and the state department in Washington and could reveal “unflattering” views that American officials held about close EU allies and countries like Russia and Turkey.

US diplomats have been visiting foreign ministries hoping to stave off anger over the cables, which are internal messages that often lack the niceties diplomats voice in public.

WikiLeaks has said the newest release will be seven times the size of the October publication of 400,000 Iraq war documents, the biggest leak to date in US intelligence history.

The site also published 77,000 classified US files on the Afghan conflict in July.

‘Violation of US law’

In his letter, Koh said the release will “place at risk the lives of countless innocent individuals,” “place at risk on-going military operations,” and “place at risk on-going cooperation between countries”.

“You have undermined your stated objective by disseminating this matieral widely, without redaction, and without regard to the security and sanctity of the lives your actions endanger,” he wrote.

Koh said WikiLeaks should return them to the US government and destroy any copies in its possession or in computer databases.

Steve Clemons discusses the diplomatic ramifications of the leak with Al Jazeera

“They were provided in violation of US law and without regard for the grave consequences of this action,” he said.

The letter also said the US government would not cooperate with WikiLeaks in trying to scrub the cables of information that might put sources and methods of intelligence gathering and diplomatic reporting at risk.

Steve Clemons, a political strategist and director of the American Strategy Programme at New America Foundation, told Al Jazeera that the US reaction to this latest round of leaks has been stronger than in the past because of mainly diplomatic concerns.

“Certainly I wouldn’t take it to the level of lives lost on the battlefield. This is essentially diplomatic brouhaha,” he said.

“I think also that the content of these documents is a lot about the gossip and innuendo and the nuance … and there are going to be a lot of embarrassing things that come out of these documents.

“There are be political repercussions of the way foreign leaders are going to read these documents. And in that sense, you’re going to see people, ranging from have everyone from [Asif Ali] Zardari In Pakistan, to, I understand, Nelson Mandela of South Africa has had some bad swipes taken at him in these cables.”

Whatever the consequences for the US, Clemons said the leaks are highlighting the extent to which governments’ reliance on secrecy has become so pervasive.

“Governments have been trying to hide themselves from embarrassment. And I think that’s what WikiLeaks is trying to create a market reaction to and trying to change.”

‘Diplomatic catastrophe’

The document release will contain more than 250,000 cables and 8,000 diplomatic directives – mostly from the last five years.

ccording to White House sources cited by a correspondent of the US website Politico, none of the documents are classified as ‘Top Secret’. But reportedly six per cent are listed as “secret” and 40 per cent as “confidential”.

Less than five per cent of the files are about EU nations, according to OWNI, a French news site with a live blog covering the “StateLogs”.

Speculation has swirled on the inclusion of cables about US ties to separatist groups in Turkey, perceptions of the UK coalition government, and allegedly corrupt politicians in several countries.

The documents could include reports from officials in Washington and diplomatic posts around the world about issues on which Britain and the US have collaborated closely, including the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Members of the former Labour administrations of Gordon Brown and Tony Blair were bracing for the flood of millions of documents.

Franco Frattini, Italy’s foreign minister, said he did not know the content of the files to be released but warned they would “blow up the relationship of trust between states”, according to Italian news agencies.

“It will be the September 11th of world diplomacy,” he said, adding that the release would be the product of “a criminal activity that has already been prosecuted in 10 countries, including the United States”.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)